Who would win in a war?
POSTED BY: bigwolf18
UPDATED: Sunday, August 30, 2026 16:25
VIEWED: 4257
PAGE 1 of 7
The Alliance? or Halo universe's UNSC?
they occur around the same tim period, within 3 decades of one another, and the technologys are about equal. I think the UNSC would win because of larger shipboard weapons, the ability to use slipspace and the SPARTAN IIs. but what do you think? we haven't seen much of the alliance military, we know they use laser based weapons, and have some kind of advanced technology weapons on their assault ships (opening scene of pilot) be it a rail gun or laser or even plasma, but who could win a war between verses?
-------------------------------------------------
"of course i've gone mad with power, ya ever tried going mad without power? its no fun, nobody listens to you!" The Simpsons Movie
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
The Alliance apparently has some kind of superweapon capable of turning an entire world, no matter how big or fertile into blackrock, and also appear to feel justified doing so in the event of conflict.
They also have psychics, which are a big tactical advantage, and might use some kind of chemical warfare.
I think because of sheer numbers, however, even though psychics might be able to turn the tide of one or two major seemingly hopeless battles, I picture the Alliance working more insidiously to win worlds.
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Mal & Zoe are fine folk, definitely above average in the war-waging arena, did better than hold their own against the best the Alliance had to throw at 'em. That said, neither strikes me as being much beyond 'standard' human. Add in a few elite units and a few dozen Operatives, and a handful of telepaths. No interstellar travel. Kudos for the planet killing weapons & the willingness to use 'em, but the only places the Alliance can deliver the weapons to are their own worlds. Lasers exist, but most of the space based anti-ship weapons appear to be missile based. Population of 50ish habitable rocks, many sparsely populated on the rim by folks that don't much care for the Alliance anyway.
The UNSC on the other hand makes use of Marines (I figure dead even match for Alliance troops), and ODSTs (Finest warriors to be found in UNSC space, each a match for an Operative at least), Spartan II's (genetically enhanced to well beyond human, and encased in shielded power armor (Mjolnir)), and Spartan III's (genetically enhanced beyond Spartan II levels, but with Semi-Powered Infiltration armor (think Predator from the movies) vs. Mjolnir armor. The UNSC also has a much larger population to draw from. UNSC space includes Earth-that-was, and hundreds of solar systems, many with multiple habitable rocks (and several that don't much care for the UNSC).
Home field advantage goes to the Alliance. Everything the UNSC uses will have to be shipped in. It's possible that at sublight (non-slip), the Alliance will have the advantage. They have to have fast ships for interplanetary shipping. The UNSC does not, they jump. Down side, the UNSC gets to set the tempo with it's jump capable ships. Drop a few nukes while still in slip-space & watch the show. The Alliance will never be able to engage until the UNSC wishes to. The UNSC can bring all of their forces to bear on a single target at once, and the Alliance cannot detect them coming. The Alliance will have to try to protect multiple targets simultaneously. They will fight bravely, but the the Alliance will be overwhelmed by sheer firepower. Imagine the scene at Mr. Universe's, except all of the incoming ships are dedicated warships, using coordinated MAC firing sequences (similar to current US AEGIS fleet anti-air coordination), and missile batteries.
Space Battle: UNSC
Once the orbital defenses have been destroyed and the fight goes to the ground, things get really grim for the Alliance.
The Alliance won the Unification War because they could out-produce the Independents, and had better technology, not because they were better fighters. The technology advantage is pretty much neutralized in this case, and the productivity advantage is in favor of the UNSC. Let's say 1 person in 1,000 is capable of being either an Operative (Alliance) or an ODST (UNSC), and the rest are Alliance Troopers or UNSC Marines. I'm guessing that the UNSC has more ODSTs than the Alliance has Troops.
Ground Battle: UNSC.
Wildcard:
If the Alliance telepaths can predict where the UNSC will jump to (or perhaps even influence the decision) so that the UNSC jumps into a trap (every Alliance cruiser & fighter, using unarmed ships as cannon fodder to allow them to close to optimal fighting distance), and the Alliance capitalizes on it's superior sublight maneuvering and speed...
Well, that might work once. Then the UNSC would slip in nukes first, and let their capital ships mop up the survivors after the primary shock waves had passed.
----------
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Good assessment. Which, like I said, is why I doubt the Alliance would engage the UNSC head on, but instead infiltrate. Even though Operatives of Parliament are highly trained in the martial arts, I suspect their greater skills lie in more clandestine areas.
As I think about it, how is it even possible the UNSC can have 800 inhabitable/terraformed colony worlds and such a high population number only five centuries in the future? I know people bring up this same point about Firefly, but in Firefly there's only 70 worlds and somewhere in the tens of billions of people, much less than the UNSC.
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
1. Quantity of telepaths
It's not clear how many Alliance has, but River was clearly their best, and it is also not clear a telepath works over electronic media or at long distance. I can understand these assets effective in small actions - to what extent strategic?
2. Alliance infantry quality
Not familiar with HALO, but I infer the Marines are volunteers, picked men, training and equipment above the average. If Alliance is a meld of Anglo and Sino, most likely alot of it is draftees, like the US during WWII. The US forces back that had about 100 divisions (if you add in all the corps level assets of independent armor and artillery battalions), but only three divisions Marines, and a few regiments of Rangers. How might the Allianc mix compare with that?
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
You know, I have my suspicions that maybe comparing infantry isn't the best way to go about this. I suspect Alliance tanks and rollers are more matched and comparable to Spartans than Operatives. Both function as anti-infantry, one is just a vehicle, as opposed to a genetically enhanced person in a power suit.
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Quote:
Originally posted by Bytemite:
As I think about it, how is it even possible the UNSC can have 800 inhabitable/terraformed colony worlds and such a high population number only five centuries in the future? I know people bring up this same point about Firefly, but in Firefly there's only 70 worlds and somewhere in the tens of billions of people, much less than the UNSC.
The development of FTL (Faster Than Light) travel. UNSC found it, Alliance didn't. Once the UNSC could travel from star to star at FTL speeds (via slip-space which, apparently bypasses special relativity) setting up colonies on hundreds of planets becomes pretty straight forward. Don't even have to terra-form 'em unless they're really close to spec already. Just keep looking for good ones.
Lots of wide open spaces, fertile ground, plenty of work to do, not much in the way of entertainment, young men, young women... Perhaps even a bit of encouragement from the government to get the ladies interested in child bearing instead of career building, at least during their prime child bearing years (or just make contraception and abortion inaccessible (oops, we didn't get those crates, but look - Double shipment of baby supplies!), or set up a "people factory" (artificial wombs) if the ladies prove reluctant...
----------
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Quote:
Originally posted by Bytemite:
Good assessment. Which, like I said, is why I doubt the Alliance would engage the UNSC head on, but instead infiltrate. Even though Operatives of Parliament are highly trained in the martial arts, I suspect their greater skills lie in more clandestine areas.
I have no doubt that if an Alliance Operative could get to a UNSC facility, (s)he could be quite a trouble maker. Hooked up with a Rebel Faction, an Operative could be very problematic for the UNSC. The trouble is, Alliance personnel can only operate in Alliance territory. They have no way to get an Operative behind UNSC lines. All of the fighting will take place in the 'Verse because of this. An Operative may remain behind on a planet taken by the UNSC & try to set up a resistance (oh the irony! Operatives fighting for Independence from a superior force that's come to meddle!), but I still suspect an Operative to be on par with an ODST, and there's gonna be a bunch of them looking for the source of the problems.
----------
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Ah, so you believe the natural reproduction rate may have been augmented with technology. That could make some sense. With just the natural reproduction rate, with most people back on more populated worlds, I couldn't imagine how there might be 800 planets populated enough to call them "colonies."
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Quote:
I have no doubt that if an Alliance Operative could get to a UNSC facility, (s)he could be quite a trouble maker. Hooked up with a Rebel Faction, an Operative could be very problematic for the UNSC. The trouble is, Alliance personnel can only operate in Alliance territory. They have no way to get an Operative behind UNSC lines. All of the fighting will take place in the 'Verse because of this. An Operative may remain behind on a planet taken by the UNSC & try to set up a resistance (oh the irony! Operatives fighting for Independence from a superior force that's come to meddle!), but I still suspect an Operative to be on par with an ODST, and there's gonna be a bunch of them looking for the source of the problems.
Except, like I said, I think Operatives have more infiltration skill and subterfuge ability than the military training you may find in higher end soldiers. Which means they could go underground detected, get into unexpected places... And I don't think all of their skills require Alliance clearance, because I'm sure there's been times they've been sent to assassinate rich businessmen who can afford security who've fled to worlds on the Border or Rim.
It's just an interesting possibility to consider. :)
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME