The Hollow Men
POSTED BY: Schism
UPDATED: Friday, January 22, 2010 16:15
VIEWED: 12829
PAGE 3 of 4
Quote:
Originally posted by LooneyLad:
The more I think about Boyd's betrayal, the less I like it as a storyline. It served as one shocking twist and then it was just kind of cliched after that.
I liked Boyd as a good guy. I really, really did. But the "Big Bad" twist had the potential to be awesome, but it kind of missed. Probably because they most likely made the twist up when they were writing The Attic episode. If there was even the subtlest of clues that Boyd was evil, then this could have been awesome. If they showed some sort of flash back and fleshed out the depth of his plot. Instead, he was just pretty much insane the whole time...
Yeah, I now start to twitch every time I think back to all those great Boyd moments, when I felt we were so lucky to have him.
It's like getting to the last episode of dueSOUTH, and finding out Fraser was really a serial killer that whole time.
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
I thought the episode was sorta flat too. Boyd seemed like such a bad actor during this episode. When we're supposed to believe that before the reveal he was a flawless actor.
I don't even entirely understand his master plan. If Echo's body is all they cared about then why the whole show? Couldn't they have taken her to a lab somewhere and gotten the spinal fluid out of her? Did they need her to end up in a composite state to really get the spinal juices flowing? It just seems like an incredibly extensive ruse for that. Especially when he could have had the entire Dollhouse set up with 100% dolls from the get go and just pulled a Truman show type thing on Echo. There's no need for all the other people with their silly free will.
I also thought team Echo was pretty stupid. Blowing up that one little building was never going to stop Rossum. There were "20 other houses". You have to assume that they have the blueprints for Topher's imprint device. You also should assume that enitre place was under surveillance. So, most likely Topher's explanation about how to fix the device was recorded and broadcast to another Rossum facility.
I guess the whole point is that team Echo was too short sighted though.
Oh and I called the flowers in a vase thing the second I saw the Millie imprint. Though I though they were going to use her against Rossum on against Ballard.
NOTIFY: N | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
When Boyd was first revealed as the founder or Rossum, I thought it was cool. I thought that maybe he had realized what a dark path his company was travelling down, maybe even at odds with the other "hims", and that he was developing Echo as a way to bring down his own house of cards. This, I liked.
Then it turned out he was just crazy.... and it got a lot less interesting.
"I thoroughly disapprove of duels. If a man should challenge me, I would take him kindly and forgivingly by the hand and lead him to a quiet place and kill him."
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
I really couldn't tell exactly what his plan was. It seemed like he wanted to take over the world and just have a select few who were immune to being programmed. Though I could also twist his words to mean that once he realized what the technology was capable of that he was working to find a way to stop it. That he knew if the tech was possible that eventually someone would use it. So, he could still have been somewhat of a good guy who was working from the inside to stop the out of control company.
No one really took the time to listen to him after they realized that he was a liar. They just reacted with hatred.
I would have liked to see them take the time to hear him out before they jumped to conclusions that he was evil. Though I still think there's a significant chance he was just evil.
NOTIFY: N | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Boyd's assumption (and a not-entirely-groundless one, given how scientific advancement tends to work) was that the outcome of this tech (i.e., the apocalypse) was inevitable. All Topher could have done was enable it to happen a few years/decades ahead of schedule. According to Boyd, there was no way to stop it.
It's kinda like Judgement Day in the Terminator universe: you cannot avoid it. All you can do is delay it (as in T1) and prepare for it (as in T2/TSCC).
(Or, alternately, like Third Impact in Evangelion. NERV can kill Angels 'till the cows come home, and then they can kill the cows, but eventually, someone will trigger Lilith and end the world. Gendo wasn't trying to avoid it, he was trying to alter the outcome by using Rei to deliberately trigger Third Impact.)
So, that was Boyd's plan. He wasn't Evil(tm), he was trying to play Messiah for his chosen people. And since he's a Darwinist, his "family" has to prove themselves --Adelle has to become the General, Topher had to develop a conscience, Echo had to become a hero. The whole show thus far was Boyd testing them, being the voice of their conscience until they learned to hear it for themselves.
Those who couldn't, whom he didn't deem worthy of "saving," well, it's the duty of a Messiah to say who gets saved and who doesn't. He did what he had to do.
Discovering Echo's mutation must have been like a sign; something that can allow a small handful to survive what's coming. As for keeping Echo active, consider that she didn't start glitching until season 2 --she wasn't "ripe" yet. I'm guessing that whatever chemicals Rossum needed from her spinal fluid needed time to build up.
(It's therefore possible that other Actives could have developed the same mutation [perhaps that's what Victor and Sierra were doing], but they didn't have Boyd cleaning up their messes --any Actives who started glitching would've been sent to the attic or separated from whatever was causing the glitch.)
By using Topher to deliberately bring about the apocalypse, Boyd can orchestrate it on his terms (rather than waiting decades for someone to master the tech on their own), and he can assemble a small group of survivors. Of course, he has no "Skynet" to fight after the apocalypse (this isn't a centralized attack, it's anarchy), so he's not putting together a rebel group, he's pulling together a family.
I'm honestly curious as to his endgame, though. It's possible that he was surrounding himself with the people he expected to die with, but maybe he was expecting the apocalypse to burn itself out --for the survivors we see in "Epitaph One" to unravel the mystery and shut down Rossum "once and for all," leaving Boyd and his happy few to take control of the rebuilding (and of a world full of blank slates, ready for imprinting as "proper" members of society).
If Topher was his Rei Ayanami then maybe Adelle was his John Connor --someone with the willpower, leadership ability, and (thanks to him) the compassion to become the future's new leader. . .
(I don't necessarily agree with him, of course. I tend to think this particular apocalypse can be averted. Now that they know about Echo's biochemistry, Topher can find a way to synthesize what they need. All Adelle and her group needs to do is delay Rossum.)
-----
We applied the cortical electrodes but were unable to get a neural reaction from either patient.
NOTIFY: N | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
They knew about Caroline's body chemistry up front. That's why he chose her. From the bone graft test that he had on file. So, he still didn't need to put her through the Dollhouse to get her to glitch. He could have faked it. Instead he put her in harms way again and again. Seems really risky if she's the only girl in all the world with the immunity.
NOTIFY: N | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Well, he knew about her potential (and I'm admittedly just guessing that Rossum became aware of Caroline after they found out about the impending apocalypse) --S1 Echo certainly wasn't shrugging off imprints like she has been lately.
He likely needed an excuse to have her continually wiped and re-imprinted before she was ready to "harvest."
And putting her (and eventually himself) in Adelle's Dollhouse made her a catalyst: Echo, Topher, and Dewitt were critical players in his game, and even Ballard, November, Victor, Sierra, and Whiskey/Saunders (we honestly don't know which one he first started manipulating) all became important in his machinations. Without Echo to pull everything together, they never would've gotten to this point.
-----
We applied the cortical electrodes but were unable to get a neural reaction from either patient.
NOTIFY: N | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
That's the problem. Without knowing his end game they really didn't seem all that important. They seemed like they grew on him and he wanted them to survive the apocalypse. That's about it. I think that episode needed to play out over 2 hours at the very least.
NOTIFY: N | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Quote:
Originally posted by Zeek:
They knew about Caroline's body chemistry up front. That's why he chose her. From the bone graft test that he had on file. So, he still didn't need to put her through the Dollhouse to get her to glitch. He could have faked it. Instead he put her in harms way again and again. Seems really risky if she's the only girl in all the world with the immunity.
They didn't know she had "immunity"...they only knew that she was different. She had to be put through the imprinting process to see what that difference meant to the wiping/imprinting process. She was an experiment under close observation...that yielded the results they probably hoped for.
I'm having a hard time digesting everything because I feel like I may be fanwanking a lot. I think that happens when a show that has a potentially seasons long arc gets rushed to closure. Would Boyd have been the big bad if the show had continued for 5 seasons? I had an unsettled feeling about him when he became head of security and for quite some time did not like him, but was that really suppose to foreshadow the revelation of him as the big bad? I keep second guessing everything and can't really get down to one cohesive idea about this episode.
I do have to agree with Boyd, however, that the remote wiping/imprinting tech would've probably come out anyway...with or without Topher's help. What really makes Boyd the bad guy is that he can foresee the end result of the tech, but instead of doing whatever he can to delay that, he is going to do whatever he can to profit from it while protecting/insulating himself from it. He's selling the A-bomb to the highest bidder all the while knowing that his bombproof shelter is going to save him and his "family" from the effects.
***************
"The power of accurate observation is commonly called cynicism by those who have not got it." - George Bernard Shaw
NOTIFY: Y | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME
Quote:
Originally posted by RugBug:
They didn't know she had "immunity"...they only knew that she was different. She had to be put through the imprinting process to see what that difference meant to the wiping/imprinting process. She was an experiment under close observation...that yielded the results they probably hoped for.
That still seems like a horrible plan considering their resources. I mean people were making jokes about how they should have a sign that says "we've gone 3 engagements without a client in mortal danger" or something. They were awful at keeping anyone even remotely safe.
If all they needed was to observe echo being imprinted then they could have just used other dolls as her engagement partners. They had 20 houses worth to play with.
I just feel like they rushed this story so much that we didn't get enough info. There's gotta be some pieces to this puzzle missing.
NOTIFY: N | REPLY | REPLY WITH QUOTE | PERMALINK | TOP | HOME